When my oldest son first started to play in a baseball league, the idea was just to have fun. Everyone got a chance to bat. They didn’t really keep track of outs and they didn’t keep score - officially. Even through there was no official score, my son and all of his friends knew exactly what the score of the game was and they were quick to declare a “winner” when the game was over.
My son and his team were not unique. As a nation, I am convinced that we keep score of just about everything, because we are a little obsessed with knowing who is winning and, just as importantly, who is losing. The numbers, as some people like to say, don’t lie and so we keep score. This week, however, I began to wonder why we feel compelled to keep score in church. You don’t see Jesus asking Peter to get a count of the crowd gathered to listen to the Sermon on the Mount, but each Sunday ushers, interested parishioners and pastors, invest time in counting how many people are in church. We record the numbers. We track them and analyze them, but why?. Why do we count how many people are in worship on Sunday mornings or how many members are on the rolls or how many persons we serve in mission?
I like to believe that we track these numbers so we can measure the progress and impact of our ministry, but sometimes I wonder how often we count simply so we can keep score, so we can create a leaderboard that shows statistics like: who is the largest and who is the smallest or who is growing the fastest and who is falling apart the quickest. Once the leaderboard is established then we can find our place and compare ourselves to others.
What would happen, do you think, if we stopped counting for a month or two? Would we find another place to direct that energy? Would we start to look for new ways to measure progress? Would our priorities and the ways we invest our time begin to change? I’d like to think all of these things would occur, but I have a feeling that in most cases we would secretly keep score, just like my son and his team did, so that when the experiment was over we could announce a winner.



